How secure is your password manager? What the BSI study shows
In short
According to the BSI report of December 2025, the ten password managers examined differ clearly in security; none of them was completely insecure.
With three of the ten programs it is, according to the report, theoretically possible for the vendor to access the stored passwords.
The BSI stresses that the benefits of password managers far outweigh the risks; what matters is a strong master password, two-factor authentication and regular updates.
In this article
How many passwords do you have to remember? And for how many services do you use the same password, just with a different number at the end? Password managers are seen as the way out: they keep your digital keys in one place. How secure these vaults are themselves has been examined by the German Federal Office for Information Security (BSI). We summarise the results. The basis is the BSI report of December 2025.
What is a password manager?
A password manager is a digital vault for your login details. You remember a single strong master password; the program does the rest. It generates complex passwords for new accounts, stores them in encrypted form and fills them in automatically when you log in.
Many password managers also synchronise the data between devices, for example from smartphone to laptop, often via the cloud. Well-known examples are 1Password, LastPass and the password manager built into Google Chrome.
The benefit: weak passwords such as “123456” and the same combination for every service become a thing of the past. According to a survey by the consumer advice centre of North Rhine-Westphalia (Verbraucherzentrale NRW), many people struggle to manage their passwords: they reuse passwords or choose simple variants. Both raise the risk of a successful attack. A password manager helps — provided it is secure itself.
What the BSI examined
The BSI examined ten common password managers, from the encryption of the data to the architecture of the system. The result: there are clear differences in security.
With three of the ten programs it is, according to the report, theoretically possible for the vendor to access the stored passwords, above all when synchronisation runs through the user account. The password manager in Google Chrome is one of them (as of December 2025). That describes a theoretical possibility, not the normal case. The BSI also stresses that the benefits of password managers far outweigh the risks.
Further weak points
The report names three further weak points:
| Weak point | What the report describes |
|---|---|
| Incomplete encryption | Some password managers do not encrypt all data. Metadata such as account names, for example, remains unprotected. |
| Weak default settings | Unless the settings are adjusted, the data can be easier to attack. |
| No re-encryption | After the master password is changed, older data is not always re-encrypted automatically. |
Even so, none of the password managers examined was completely insecure. Many offer strong cryptography and protection against common attacks such as phishing. The BSI sees room for improvement and has given the vendors feedback.
Data protection: who sees your data?
Alongside security, the study looked at data protection. For this the Verbraucherzentrale NRW reviewed the privacy policies and the registration process. The result: most providers handle the data responsibly. Some, however, collect more information than necessary, for example for marketing purposes.
Two recommendations follow. Read the privacy notice before you register. And for synchronisation via the cloud, choose a password manager with zero-knowledge encryption: with it, the provider does not see your passwords.
Six practical recommendations
On the basis of the report we recommend six steps:
- Choose carefully. Be guided by independent tests such as this one. Look for strong encryption, for example AES-256, and make sure the vendor has no access to your data.
- Pick a strong master password. It should be long and unique, for example a whole sentence along the lines of “MyDogLovesWalks2026!”.
- Switch on two-factor authentication. It gives the vault additional protection.
- Set your own passphrase in Google Chrome. If you use the password manager there, set a passphrase of your own for synchronisation. That prevents access by the vendor (as of December 2025).
- Update regularly. Keep the application up to date so that security vulnerabilities are closed.
- Consider alternatives. If you do not trust the cloud, there are password managers that work offline and open-source programs such as Bitwarden.
What this means for your company
A password manager is better than none: it makes handling login details more secure and simpler. That applies all the more when several people access the same systems.
In a company, more than a single account depends on login details. Hosting, shop back end, domain, payment and shipping accounts each have their own access. When we take over a shop as part of our shop support, securing that access is therefore the first step.
The same principles apply to the login of your website. As part of website maintenance we secure the login, set up two-factor authentication and limit login attempts. With WordPress, securing the login is one of the security measures of our WordPress agency, alongside daily backups and malware monitoring.
Source
Report by the Federal Office for Information Security (BSI), December 2025.
Frequently asked questions
What is a password manager?
A digital vault for login details. You remember a single strong master password; the program generates complex passwords, stores them in encrypted form and fills them in automatically when you log in.
What did the BSI examine in password managers?
Ten common password managers, from the encryption of the data to the architecture of the system. According to the report of December 2025 there are clear differences in security; none of the programs was completely insecure.
Can the vendor see our passwords?
With three of the ten programs examined this is theoretically possible according to the BSI report of December 2025, above all when synchronisation runs through the user account. With zero-knowledge encryption the provider does not see the passwords.
Which weak points does the report name?
Three: incomplete encryption that leaves metadata such as account names unprotected, weak default settings, and older data that is not re-encrypted after the master password is changed.
Should we still use a password manager?
Yes. The BSI stresses that the benefits of password managers far outweigh the risks. What matters is a strong master password, two-factor authentication and regular updates.
Questions about this topic?
Thirty minutes with a developer, free of charge and with no sales pressure.
Book a free consultationRelated services
Shop support
Shop support: operations, monitoring and continuous improvement
Website maintenance
Website maintenance: your site keeps running without you thinking about it
WordPress agency
WordPress agency: fast websites, not plugin stacks
More articles
All topics and articlesSoftware
Software development trends: what they offer companies
AI, low-code, edge computing, DevSecOps, PWAs: what is behind the trends in software development and what they offer companies. Read the article now.
Web & operations
Important information on the critical PHP vulnerability (“PHP2Shell”): your systems at Clickservice are secure!
PHP2Shell (CVE-2026-109618, CVE-2026-109619): what happened, how Clickservice responded and why our customers do not need to take any action at all.
AI & automation
AI in e-commerce: 5 processes that already pay off today
Five processes in online retail where AI already saves work today, from product copy to reading orders, with prerequisites and limits. Read the article now.
About the author
Clickservice
Clickservice is a digital agency in Vienna for ERP integration, e-commerce and custom software.
Let's talk about your project
An article explains the principle. What applies to your system is settled in the first call: thirty minutes with a developer, free of charge and with no sales pressure.
- Reply within 24 hours on working days